Elmer Hinckley

Another classic size shared amongst many Finger Lake spoon makers dating back to start of Elmer Hinckley Fishing Tackle. A Louis Wehle contest winner, catches Large Trout, Musky, and Northern Pike. Originally made with a bucktail tied treble hook. With hooks removed this spoon...

A Naples flutter spoon that fell out of production, a fast favorite for anyone who uses it. Water tests have caught every species of trout. A slower trolling spoon with a good wobble that triggers strikes.   Available Options Color Solid: Silver  Gold  Copper  Lacquered-Copper ...

A Louis A. Wehle contest winning spoon with good reason. A versatile spoon that catches any trout or salmon species. Highly effective for lead core trolling brown trout.   Available Options   Color Solid: Silver  Gold  Copper  Lacquered-Copper  Black-Nickel Two-Tone: Nickel/Black-Nickel  Nickel/Copper  Nickel/Lacquered-Copper  Nickel/Gold Finish Smooth ...

One of the smaller Hinckley flutter spoons effective on all species. Brook trout fisherman use this spoon on spinning tackle in smaller lakes and streams. Open water tests with this spoon produced vicisious stirkes and produced when fish were finiky.   Available Options  ...

Origins of the design date back to Naples with many of Elmer’s big fish caught in Keuka Lake with this spoon. Many hand cut orignials can still be found and fished with great success.   Available Options Color Solid: Silver  Gold  Copper  Lacquered-Copper  Black-Nickel Two-Tone: Nickel/Black-Nickel ...

An original NY flutter spoon, dating far back to Naples and the finger lakes. Slimmer than an 88 with same thickness This spoon is another effective spoon that can handle faster speeds and catch a variety of fish.   Available Options Color Solid: Silver  Gold ...

A popular style flutter spoon that catches all species of trout. Elmer had this in his collection, however he preferred the action from his wider designs. Water test of old stock proved sucessful due to the spoons ability to handle a variety of speeds...

A common size amongst many Finger Lake spoon makers dating back to Naples, The Hinckley 88 is another Louis Wehle contest winning spoon from the 50’s. A heavy thumping spoon geared towards slower speeds, however we’ve had reports of success pushing faster. A classic...

One of 3 custom made spoons by Mary Misel in the 50’s for Wade Van Vranken. The most popular of the three and a go to for Great Lakes fishermen for Lake Trout. Common set up for Seth Green rigs the long thin spoon...